September 26, 2025

How to Make a Winning Offer in a Competitive Market

How to Make a Winning Offer in a Competitive Market

Navigating today’s fast-paced real estate market—especially in highly sought-after areas like Arlington, VA—can be overwhelming. With low housing inventory, high buyer demand, and rising interest rates, buyers are competing for a limited number of homes. In such an environment, making a strong, strategic offer is essential. This article outlines expert strategies that can help serious homebuyers in Arlington, VA, and beyond craft compelling offers that get noticed—and accepted.

Get Pre-Approved, Not Just Pre-Qualified

In competitive markets, pre-qualification won’t cut it. Sellers want to know a buyer is financially capable of closing the deal. A pre-approval letter from a reputable lender demonstrates that a buyer has gone through the underwriting process and is ready to act quickly. In Arlington, VA, where homes often receive multiple offers within days, this step alone can put a buyer at the top of the seller’s list.

Work with a Local Real Estate Expert

Partnering with an experienced, locally focused agent can be a game-changer. Agents who know the Arlington, VA, market inside and out can offer strategic insight on pricing, advise when to waive contingencies, and tap into off-market listings. They can also build rapport with the listing agent—an often overlooked but crucial factor in getting an offer accepted.

Make a Strong First Offer

In a seller’s market, coming in with a lowball offer is rarely a winning tactic. Instead, buyers should work with their agent to craft a compelling, competitive offer based on comparable sales and the home’s condition. In Arlington, VA, many homes sell for above asking price, so making a strong initial offer can deter competing bids and show the seller the buyer is serious.

Consider Escalation Clauses

An escalation clause automatically increases your offer by a specified increment if a competing bid is received—up to a set maximum. For example, if a home is listed at $750,000, and the buyer submits an offer of $755,000 with a clause to beat any higher offer by $5,000 (up to $775,000), the seller gets the best of both worlds. This clause can be a powerful tool in Arlington's fast-moving real estate landscape, but it should be used with caution and professional guidance.

Waive Contingencies Wisely

Contingencies protect the buyer, but in a hot market, too many can make an offer less appealing. Common contingencies include financing, appraisal, and home inspection. While waiving all contingencies can be risky, strategically waiving or tightening certain ones—such as offering a short inspection window—can make a buyer’s offer more competitive without fully compromising protection. In Arlington, VA, where homes often sell in under 10 days, this can make a significant difference.

Offer a Flexible Timeline

Sellers often have their own timing needs. Whether they need a quick close or extra time to find a new home, accommodating their schedule can give a buyer a competitive edge. Flexibility on closing dates or even offering post-settlement occupancy can be the deciding factor in multiple-offer situations. In markets like Arlington, VA, where seller preferences vary widely, adaptability can seal the deal.

Write a Personal Letter

A well-crafted letter to the seller can humanize the offer and create an emotional connection. While not always effective, many sellers in Arlington, VA, still appreciate the gesture—especially those with a deep personal attachment to their home. Buyers should briefly introduce themselves, explain what they love about the home, and express genuine appreciation for the opportunity to submit an offer.

Increase the Earnest Money Deposit

An earnest money deposit (EMD) signals to the seller that the buyer is committed. While 1-2% of the purchase price is common, offering a larger deposit—especially in Arlington, VA’s competitive environment—can demonstrate financial strength and seriousness. The EMD goes toward the down payment or closing costs, so it's not additional money lost if the deal goes through.

Don’t Overlook the Appraisal Gap

In fast-appreciating areas like Arlington, VA, homes may not appraise for the full offer amount. To stay competitive, some buyers include an “appraisal gap guarantee,” pledging to pay a set amount over the appraised value (within reason). This reduces the risk for the seller and can make the offer more attractive without waiving the appraisal contingency entirely.

Act Fast, But Stay Informed

Speed matters. In Arlington, VA, homes can go under contract in just a few days—or even hours. Buyers should be prepared to tour homes the day they hit the market and submit offers quickly. However, speed should not come at the cost of due diligence. Buyers should still review disclosures, assess property condition, and understand neighborhood comps to make an informed decision, even on a tight timeline.

Invest in Pre-Offer Inspections

Some buyers in Arlington, VA, opt for pre-offer inspections on competitively priced homes. These inspections occur before submitting an offer, allowing buyers to waive the inspection contingency with confidence. While this comes with a financial risk if the offer isn’t accepted, it can make the offer more appealing and reduce post-contract negotiations.

Be Realistic About Budget and Limits

Bidding wars can create emotional decision-making. Buyers should establish their absolute budget beforehand and stick to it. In Arlington, VA, where median home prices are well above the national average, it’s easy to get swept up in the competition. A clear understanding of one’s financial boundaries ensures long-term stability and avoids buyer’s remorse.

Preparation Wins the Race

Success in a competitive real estate market isn’t about luck—it’s about preparation, knowledge, and decisiveness. Buyers in Arlington, VA, who partner with a seasoned agent, understand market trends, and craft intentional, strong offers are far more likely to succeed. Each decision, from financing to contingencies, contributes to the strength of the offer. By staying focused, flexible, and strategic, buyers can confidently navigate even the most intense markets and secure the home they love.

Work With Experts Who Know How to Win

For buyers looking to make winning offers in Arlington, VA, and the surrounding areas, The Keri Shull Team brings unparalleled local expertise and a proven track record of success. Their team of experienced professionals understands how to structure offers that stand out in a crowded field and will guide buyers through each step of the process with confidence and clarity. Whether buying a first home or upgrading to a dream property, The Keri Shull Team has the tools and market knowledge to help clients succeed in even the most competitive real estate markets.



main secondary

Meet the Author - KS Team

Ranked as the Top Producing Real Estate Team in the DC Metro area, Keri Shull and her team have sold nearly $5 billion of local real estate. The team has helped thousands of families buy or sell their home in VA, DC, & MD. Keri offers her clients several GUARANTEE programs that eliminate the typical risks associated with buying or selling properties. Get in touch today for amazing results!

Here are Some Similar Articles We’ve Recently Published

View all posts

Work With Us

We offer our clients several guarantee programs that eliminate the typical risks associated with buying or selling properties. Get in touch today for amazing results!

Follow Us